10 Mistakes First-Time Founders Make

Launching your first startup is an exhilarating journey, but it’s also riddled with blind spots. At Interplay, we’ve worked closely with a ton of early-stage companies and seen firsthand the common traps that first-time founders fall into. While mistakes are part of the process, some are avoidable - and avoiding them could be the difference between scaling your startup or shutting down prematurely.

In this post, we’ll break down 10 of the most common mistakes first-time founders make, along with guidance on how to avoid them, especially if you’re considering applying to a startup incubator.

1. Building Without Validating the Problem First

Are You Solving a Real Pain Point?

Too many founders get caught up in their product idea without deeply understanding whether there’s a real problem or if people even care about solving it.

Why this happens:

• Passion blinds objectivity.
• “If we build it, they will come” mindset.

How to avoid it:

• Conduct 100+ customer discovery interviews.
• Use tools like surveys, lean canvas, and MVP testing.
• Make sure your problem is painful, urgent, and frequent.

2. Choosing the Wrong Co-Founder

Is Your Co-Founder Complementary or a Clone?

Starting a business with the wrong person is one of the hardest mistakes to fix later.

Common pitfalls:

• Choosing friends over qualified partners.
• Not defining clear roles and responsibilities.
• Avoiding difficult conversations early.

What to do instead:

• Choose someone with complementary skill sets.
• Discuss equity, values, and vision upfront.
• Create a founder’s agreement early.

3. Ignoring the Importance of Go-to-Market Strategy

How Will You Actually Get Customers?

A great product without a clear go-to-market (GTM) plan is a common failure point.

Why this is a mistake:

• Founders often focus on features, not distribution.
• GTM is assumed to be “figure-it-out-later.”

Fix it by:

• Identifying your customer acquisition channels early.
• Testing messaging, pricing, and positioning constantly.
• Prioritizing traction over perfection.

4. Underestimating the Time and Capital Needed

Have You Planned for the Long Haul?

Running out of money or time is the most common cause of startup failure.

Why this happens:

• Overly optimistic projections.
• Not understanding the fundraising landscape.
• Not building in a buffer for unexpected delays.

How to avoid it:

• Build a realistic 18-24 month runway.
• Assume everything will take twice as long and cost twice as much.
• Start fundraising conversations early.

5. Not Talking to Users Enough

Are You Listening or Assuming?

Founders often fall into the trap of thinking they already know what users want.

Why this is dangerous:

• Lack of real-world feedback leads to feature bloat.
• You might build something no one uses.

What to do instead:

• Set a cadence for weekly user interviews.
• Incorporate feedback into sprints.
• Treat product development as a conversation, not a monologue.

6. Spending Too Much Too Early

Is Your Burn Rate Killing Your Startup?

It’s tempting to spend on fancy offices, branding, or hiring before finding product-market fit.

What’s going wrong here:

• Founders think raising money = success.
• Egos get attached to appearances.

Better approach:

• Stay lean until you’ve validated your model.
• Focus on revenue and retention.
• Every dollar should get you closer to product-market fit.

7. Avoiding Help and Feedback

Are You Trying to Do It All Alone?

Founders often hesitate to seek mentorship or admit they don’t have all the answers.

Why this happens:

• Fear of appearing weak.
• Not knowing where to find the right advice.
  
  

How to fix it:

• Join an incubator or accelerator with a strong mentor network.
• Surround yourself with experienced operators.
• Get feedback early and often.

8. Waiting Too Long to Launch

Are You Chasing Perfection?

Delaying your launch for a “perfect” product often results in wasted time and missed opportunities.

Common causes:

• Fear of judgment.
• Perfectionist tendencies.

Better path:

• Launch a Minimum Viable Product (MVP).
• Learn from real users.
• Iterate fast and publicly.

9. Neglecting Legal and Financial Infrastructure

Are You Building on a Shaky Foundation?

Skipping early legal and financial setup can lead to chaos (and lawsuits) later on.

Mistakes to watch out for:

• Not incorporating properly.
• Ignoring cap table hygiene.
• Forgetting about IP, taxes, and compliance.

Smart move:

• Work with startup-savvy lawyers and accountants.
• Set up clean financials from day one.
• Use founder-friendly tools for equity and governance.

10. Not Thinking Big Enough

Are You Playing Too Small?

Many first-time founders start with a small solution that doesn’t scale—or appeal to investors.

Why this matters:

• Venture capital rewards big, scalable visions.
• Small markets = small exits.
  
  

Think bigger by:

• Defining a long-term, global vision.
• Starting small but articulating a path to expansion.
• Focusing on a wedge strategy to enter a large market.

Ready to Avoid These Mistakes?

There are different ways to avoid these mistakes. As mentioned above, getting mentorship and advice from folks who have navigated the choppy startup waters is one great way. Another way is to join incubators and accelerators like the Interplay Incubator. In addition to a $50K check, our incubator creates a bespoke six month program to help with our portco’s unique needs. If you’re interested in learning more, apply to our Interplay Incubator here.

FAQs About Common First-Time Founder Mistakes

How can a startup incubator help me avoid these mistakes?

A strong incubator like Interplay offers structured guidance, mentorship, and access to experts who’ve seen it all. You won’t be building alone, and you’ll avoid rookie missteps that cost time and money.

What is the most common mistake new founders make?

The most common? Building a product before validating the problem. This wastes time and capital and often leads to rebuilding from scratch.

How early should I join an incubator?

As early as possible. Many of the most critical decisions—co-founder choice, market validation, GTM planning—happen in the first few months. That’s where a program like Interplay’s shines.

What if I’ve already made some of these mistakes?

You’re not alone. What matters is course correction. Interplay works with founders at early stages to help you pivot, rebuild, and move forward the right way.

‍